What’s It Worth? Take a closer look Get the app

Who Painted the Bearded Man? Following a P. Licatti Signature

A dusty oil portrait from a Waterford estate sale, a hard-to-read signature, and a search that led to São Paulo.

The man in the painting had his own lamp. It was a little brass-colored picture light, aimed directly at the forehead of a man who looked as if he had been asked to sit still for quite long enough. I found him at an estate sale in Waterford, Michigan, in what looked like an art collector’s home. Dust had settled along the black frame and into the gold trim. Even without the lamp, I could see him looking back at me from across the room.

Detail of an oil portrait of a bearded man with pale blue eyes and a textured ochre background
The face that caught my eye at the Waterford estate sale.

The name in the lower left

I could make out a few strokes near the lower-left corner. Two tall lines shared a crossbar that seemed to go on forever. The rest took some squinting. I put two photos into What’s It Worth?, one of the whole painting and one of the signature. I told it that it was an oil painting from an estate sale. The first thing it gave me to go on was a reading of the signature. “P. Licatti.”

Close-up of the faint signature at the lower left of the painting beside the dusty gold and black frame
The mark the app read as “P. Licatti.” Follow the long crossbar toward the right edge of the signature.

The scan surfaced the fuller name José Paulo Licatti in the listings. Two of the listings appeared to show the same painting. One asked $175, the other $225, and the scan found no confirmed sale. The app put the estimated resale range at $125 to $200 and marked its confidence in that price low. A name can get copied from one listing to the next just as easily as a photo can. I wanted to see what the signature looked like on a different picture.

What’s It Worth? Results for an oil portrait signed P. Licatti, with medium identification confidence, low pricing confidence, and an estimated resale range of $125 to $200
The scan gave me a name to look up. It flagged the price as a rough estimate based on a small set of listings.

What I found on the back

A Brazilian dealer catalogues another bearded portrait under José Paulo Licatti’s name, this one a small oil on panel. I found another useful comparison in Franciscano, a work dated 1975 by the dealer who documents it. The dealer reads the signature as “P. Licatti” and records a São Paulo fine arts association seal on the reverse. I went looking for another signature and came away wanting another photo. The other bearded portrait and Franciscano

In Dive Deeper, the app asked me to turn the painting over and look for a gallery sticker, a stamp, or the artist’s full name. It also wanted the dimensions inside the frame. I turned him over. The back was blank.

I kept the name in my notes with a question mark. I still don’t know who the man in the painting is, and he looks entirely comfortable with that arrangement.

Try it on the thing you cannot name

What’s It Worth? is free to try on iPhone and Android. Photograph it, get a starting read, and keep adding what the camera could not see until the picture is honest.

Estimates are informational and not a certified appraisal.