The Norman Rockwell came with a certificate folded into panels. I expected it to tell me who the picture was by. I already knew who it was by. What I wanted to know was whether the thing in the frame had ever been anywhere near him.
I’d start by scanning the front in What’s It Worth? to identify the image, Stockbridge Main Street at Christmas. That gives me something to look up. Then I’d add the certificate in Dive Deeper and ask a better question. Which version of the picture does this paperwork describe?
Read what the small print authorizes
Rockwell made the picture in 1967. The certificate with this framed canvas carries a 1991 copyright and says the Rockwell family authorized a reproduction. I had three things to keep straight before I could compare prices: the painting, the foldout in McCall’s, and this later canvas. The snowy street appears on all three. The little word reproduction is what sends you to the right shelf. The full story of the framed Rockwell and the Norman Rockwell Museum’s artwork record
Find out how the image got onto this sheet
An original print can exist in multiple impressions. Hokusai’s Great Wave was made as a woodblock print. The Met owns two impressions dated about 1830–32, and the thin line by the right-hand boat looks different in the two. Those differences belong to the history of making the print. A modern poster made from a photograph of one of those sheets reproduces that sheet, with its peculiar little break and all. The Met’s guide to prints (PDF) and the two Great Wave impressions side by side
Ask to see what the frame hides
Get a photo of the entire sheet if the edges are already accessible, plus close-ups of the lower margin and anything written on the reverse. Record the paper dimensions separately from the size of the frame. A pencil signature, an edition number, or a publisher’s line gives you something to compare against a catalogue entry. Check whether the signature sits on top of the sheet or appears in the printed image. One clue by itself can leave several versions in play.
In Dive Deeper, ask What would identify this particular edition, and which detail should I photograph next? Compare asking prices once you can describe the thing in the frame well enough to search for it. How to start from a saved listing photo.